Saturday, July 12, 2008

Toki wo kakeru shôjo (The Girl Who Leapt Through Time, Mamoru Hosada, 2006)

Leaping to the top of her class

Mamoru Hosada's Toki wo kakeru shojo (The Girl Who Leapt Through Time, 2006) is easily the finest animated feature to come out in recent years (never mind Dreamworks' fitfully amusing if infantile Kung Fu Panda or Pixar's shamelessly Chaplinesque and overly sentimental Wall.E, both released this year). If anything, I'd call the film the best animated feature since Hayao Miyazaki's own anti-war epic Hauru no ugoku shiro (Howl's Moving Castle, 2004) some two years previous (Diana Wynne Jones' novel wasn't so clearly anti-war--but this was just after the U.S. invasion and occupation of Iraq, and the impact of its firebombing scenes in the context of the times (arguably the first great film on the war) is unforgettable).

It's not as if Hosada was in Miyazaki's league--far as I can see, he's been director of a One Piece feature and some Digimon episodes, and was key animator to both a Crying Freeman and Galaxy Express 999 sequel. But he's teamed with excellent collaborators: Gainax's character designer Yoshiyuki Sadomoto (Shin seiki Evangelion (Neon Genesis Evangelion, 1996), Ôritsu uchûgun Oneamisu no tsubasa (Wings of Honneamise, 1987)), art director Nizou Yamamoto (Mononoke Hime (Princess Mononoke, 1997); Hotaru no haka (Grave of the Fireflies, 1988)), all working on a novel by Yasutaka Tsutsui (Paprika, 2006) written way back in 1967.

Actually, the film's relationship to its source material's more interesting than that: Tsutsui (a popular novelist and science fiction writer) has had his novel adapted many times, including two live-action features, a TV movie, and at least two mini-series; this is the first time the story has been turned into an anime feature, and it's not a direct translation, more like a sequel (the main character from Tsutsui's novel makes an appearance here as the protagonist Makoto Konno's (Riisa Naka) beautiful but mysterious aunt).

Have not seen any of its previous incarnations, but from what I understand, they are straightforward adaptations of Tsutsui's time-travel romance (set in a Japanese high school) with its bittersweet conclusion. Tokikake (as it's often fondly nicknamed) belongs roughly in the shojo (girl) fiction genre, in particular "realistic school life romantic comedies" with a twist of fantasy (time travel, to be exact) to spice things up (yep, Japanese anime has that many sub-sub-sub genres).

If we cast a bit wider, time travel fiction is a time-honored literary genre (everyone from Mark Twain to H.G. Wells to Robert Heinlein to Ray Bradbury has written on the subject); paradoxical fiction, or fiction where dilemmas are created through the journeying of a time-traveler, is at least as old as Heinlein's short story "By His Bootstraps" (1941), as recent as Richard Matheson's novel Bid Time Farewell (1975), James Cameron's Terminator movies and TV series (1984 to present day), and any number of Star Trek (from 1966 to the upcoming 2009 feature) and Doctor Who episodes.

(Steven Moffat's scripts for Dr. Who in particular are fond of twisting linear time lines into witty little knots; actually his entire output (to paraphrase Jean-Luc Godard) from Coupling (2000 - 2004) to Jekyll (2007) tends to tell stories with a beginning, a middle, and an end--but rarely in that order. His script for Blink (2007) brilliantly pieces together a convoluted plot (it begins with an innocent girl encountering the video image of the fully aware Doctor, ends with the thoroughly forewarned girl briefing a newly arrived Doctor) in such a way that full understanding occurs only at the end of the story (with plenty of tension--and not a little poignancy--generated along the way); his relatively simpler Girl in a Fireplace (2006), where the Doctor skips across moments important and unimportant in a young woman's life like a stone along a pond's surface, captures the piercing transience of time--it waits for no man, not even a Time Lord, and before even he realizes it, the moment's gone).

Seen from this context, one can appreciate how difficult it is to try tell a time-travel story with any conviction or sense of coherence (time travel stories are open to paradoxes and plot loopholes, and the film has more than its fair share (if, for example (spoilers galore within the parenthesis!), the jump count changed when Makoto was brought backwards doesn't the jump count change every time she makes a leap? Why, considering the rules and their consequences, does Makoto admit to knowing about time-leaping--and why does telling a lie (or at least a prevarication) seem to make a difference? Why, if they care for each other so much, doesn't he take her with him? Or, conversely, doesn't he stay with her?)), much less introduce anything even remotely fresh to the genre.

Hosada and scriptwriter Satoko Okudera interpreting Tsutsui to their credit don't even try; the girl without much ado stumbles (literally) onto the device and starts jumping back and forth, and the film's first half is a fleet-footed comedy about what a Japanese high school girl might do with time travel, given half the chance. "I was glad an idiot (got it)" a character says; "I was worried about someone using it for bad things." You can't help but agree--if the device had fallen into the hands of an evil man, we'd have had an overwrought shonen (boy) drama full of gigantic mecha bristling with energy weapons, and very little of the delicately wrought humor Hosada and his team brings to this effort.

Where Hosada and Okudera alter Tsutsui's material most radically is in exploring the consequences of one's actions through time travel; they manage to use repeated motifs and incidents to create dark, even tragic effects (the incident with the fire extinguisher could easily have involved a handgun; as it is, the young man's feelings are unsettlingly raw and intense, and understandably so; we are taking a brief foray into the subject of bullying in Japanese schools). With Makoto's central dilemma we leave behind mere manipulation of people's feelings and step (lightly, always lightly) into the realm of tragic inevitability (we all must die; it's a matter of when and how).

Hosada was slated to direct Hauru no ugoku shiro before Miyazaki took over, and it's no small irony that his film has the feel of much of Studio Ghibli's "school life" anime (I'm thinking of the delightful Umi ga Kikoeru (Ocean Waves, 1993); Mimi wo sumaseba (Whispers of the Heart, 1995), and master Isao Takahata's lyrical Omihide poro poro (Only Yesterday, 1991)). Hosada doesn't have the graceful minimalism of Takahata (the time traveling, while a lightly used gimmick, is still a gimmick; Takahata's heroine travels through time as well, but doesn't use anything so clumsy--memory is her secret technique); this film, however, can be compared to Studio Ghibli's works with little embarrassment--high praise, in my book.

As for the criticism that this could as easily have been made into a live action film--frankly, I'm tired of that old canard. Animation film directors choose to do their work in their chosen field, and in this particular case I think Hosada does a superb job. Some effects--of Makoto running a length of street (her relentless panting, pumping limbs, fluttering cloth); of Makoto sitting at a beachside (distant pedestrians walking in one ear and out the next, it seems, in a foreshortened shot that makes one think of Gulliver in Lilliput); of Tokyo frozen in time (Hosada's camera moves about suspended objects in a way that eerily (it's the emotional impact that makes the effect unique) evokes depth and space)--would make any filmmaker from any medium sit up and take notice. A lovely, lovely film.

(First published in Businessworld, 7.11.08)

The Girl Who Leapt Through Time is one of the films in the J-Pop Anime Matsuri section of the ongoing Eiga Sai 2008 Japanese Film Festival. Eiga Sai 2008 is ongoing until July 13 at Shangri-La Plaza; and will screen on Aug. 7-10 at the Cultural Center of the Philippines; and Aug. 11-14 and 15 at the UP Film Institute. J-Pop Anime Matsuri, meanwhile, will run from July 26-27 at the Shangri-La Plaza. All films will be shown with English subtitles. For more information, go to or call 811-6155 to 58. Admission is free


john marzan said...

hayao's next film is ponyo on a cliff. i'd be interested in reading your review when it comes out.

and can you also recommend which films i should see on the current eiga sai at the shang?

linda linda linda looks like the only one that i'd be interested in watching.

Noel Vera said...

I take it you've seen this one? I'm betting it's the best film in the festival.

john marzan said...

no, i haven't seen it yet, but after reading a short review of the film, it reminded me of the Haruhi Suzumiya episode 12 ("Live Alive") that i have already seen.

Noel Vera said...

Pleasure is in the details, usually. If I were to bet on a movie, it'd be that one.

Michael Kerpan said...

Hosoda seems to be closer (overall) to the Takahata side of the Ghibli tradition than to the Miyazaki side. I actually like Girl Who Leapt Through Time MORE than Miyazaki's Howl's Moving Castle (which I do like, mind you).

This is a lot better than the first live-action version as well (haven't seen any of the others). I rate this and (just behind
this) Tekkon Kinkreet as the best Asian animated feature films since Spirited Away.

Michael Kerpan said...

Linda Linda Linda is my favorite among the films on the EIGASAI 2008 schedule. Girl Who Leapt Through Time is also very worth seeing. Pictures (and comments) at:

(Visually a lot more lovely than Haruhi Suzumiya).

Canary might also be worth seeing. It has a lot of points of interest, even if it is not (IMHO) fully successful.

Noel Vera said...

I think I had a chance to see Tekonkinkreet in Jeonju, didn't in favor of the Amazing Fast Food Grifters and some Korean anime I can't remember the title of. Pity.

Thanks for the recommendations re: Eiga Sai. I think they did much better when they were doing a Kurosawa Kyoshi retrospective, though.

Michael Kerpan said...

Well, I like Kiyoshi Kurosawa's work -- but Linda Linda Linda is my most loved film of the past 3 years (and not just because I have a crush on Bae Doo-na) -- and GWLTT is my favorite animated film from the same period. So -- I would probably prefer this year's schedule.

Canary features a return to the screen (after many decades) of one of Ozu's stars from the silent era -- Yukiko Inoue (who retired -- in her 20s -- in 1935 or so). Inoue only plays a supporting role, but it is still nice to see her. Sadly all her Ozu films are lost (but there are Naruse, Gosho and Shimizu films that survive).

Noel Vera said...

Linda Linda Linda over Kurosawa Kyoshi? That better be a damned good movie...

john marzan said...


Michael Kerpan said...

> Linda Linda Linda over Kurosawa Kyoshi?
> That better be a damned good movie..

Depends on what you think about asweet, gentle Ozu-esque (or more properly Shimizu-esque) film about 4 school girls getting ready to perform punk rock covers (of songs by the late great Blue Hearts) at their annual school festival. Although the whole cast is wonderful, Bae Doo-na (as a Korean exchange student) is extraordinary (as usual). This was a very expensive discovery. Not only did we buy the unsubbed Japanese DVD and the later subbed US onem we also had to get the soundtrack CD, multiple CDs of The Blue Hearts, multiple CDs of Base Ball Bear (the real band of the bass player in the film) and various other odds and ends. Some pictures (etc.):

Being forewarned, some people have found this dull -- as nothing goes on in the film but everyday life. ;~}

Noel Vera said...

Will check out Linda Linda Linda one of these days, let you know.

If you ever had the pleasure, I recommend Steven Moffat (if you haven't already seen anything he's written). My complete text this Friday will have a longer appreciation of his works, and how they play with linear narratives, in some ways a more sophisticated, inventive manner than this film does.

Michael Kerpan said...

Steven Moffat (as in the Dr. Who writer)?

Actually my main reason for loving GWLTT was not the structure, but the characters (esp. the heroine) and the overall quality of the art work. These were the aspects that made this so much more impressive than the live-action movie.

Noel Vera said...

Yeah, Moffat. In terms of emotional impact, his 'Girl in the Fireplace' in particular ain't chopped liver.

Time travle stories usually have their share of paradoxes; Girl Who Leapt had a little more than most. Agree, the characters are endearing--watched it with someone who loved it so much she watched it again, but even she couldn't help pointing out the plot holes.

Cde. said...

Do seek out Linda Linda Linda. It really is a wonderful film.